For some people, one of the greatest challenges of the day is falling asleep. The prevalence of insomnia (difficulty sleeping) among the general population has been on the rise in recent years, with a 2021 CDC study reporting that over 75% of high school students averaged less than 8 hours of sleep per night (CDC). A study published by the National Library of Medicine the following year also found that about a third of adults experienced some range of insomnia symptoms (Morin, Jarrin). With the ever-increasing pressures of work and school, a good night’s sleep is one of the most valuable commodities one can get. It is these pressures that turn people towards artificial methods to improve their sleep quality, one of the most common tools being over-the-counter supplement melatonin. About 20% of adolescents (National Library of Medicine) and 27% of adults (Sleep Foundation) report taking melatonin supplements to help them sleep. However, with limited research around the actual effects of melatonin and inconsistency in marketed amounts sold, in the middle of the night, most people’s first instinct is not to read the label of the bottle promising to help them fall asleep faster. So, what does melatonin actually do to us?

Melatonin is a naturally produced hormone in the brain that regulates the sleep-wake cycle, essentially signaling the body to fall asleep at night and wake up in the morning. Melatonin levels typically peak after sundown, and darkness signals the body to retreat into rest mode. However, feelings of stress late at night can decrease the natural production of melatonin, contributing to symptoms of insomnia. This is because stress causes the body to produce a hormone called cortisol that decreases melatonin production in the brain (Lam Clinic). To curb this phenomenon, many people turn to melatonin supplements to boost their melatonin levels and help them fall asleep more easily. Melatonin supplements are most commonly sold in gummy or tablet forms, with doses typically ranging from 0.3 to up to 20 milligrams. Many doctors recommend sticking to lower doses between 1 and 5 milligrams, because they can be equally, if not more, effective than larger doses. Melatonin is not commonly known to cause short-term side effects; however, side effects observed include drowsiness, headaches, and dizziness. Adequate research on the long-term effects of regular melatonin usage is very minimal, and so far, no such prevalent side effects have been observed. Melatonin is not an addictive substance, nor does it cause your body to become chemically dependent on it. However, melatonin is sold as an over-the-counter supplement, not as a medication, so FDA regulations are much less stringent and allow for false advertising about what is actually inside the bottle. There have been many instances in which the supplement contained more (or less) melatonin than was printed on the label.
Another aspect of melatonin that lacks extensive research is its impact on the brain’s dream cycle. Dreaming most commonly occurs during the REM stage of sleep, with more vivid and memorable dreams associated with that phase than with non-REM. Higher levels of melatonin in the body can prolong the REM stage, increasing the likelihood of vivid dreaming or memorable nightmares. Vivid dreams and nightmares are not uncommon reported side effects of taking melatonin, with a study from the Sleep Foundation earlier this year finding that 17% of melatonin users reported experiencing vivid dreams and nightmares more frequently as a side effect (Summer). However, there is limited research as to why people experience vivid dreams and nightmares in the first place. Overall, for a supplement as commonly consumed by the general public as melatonin, there is a surprising lack of research on long-term effects, how it affects different areas of the brain, and regulatory oversight to ensure people are actually buying what the label says they are. So, as far as we know, melatonin is a safe sleep aid at lower doses, just be on the lookout for the potential for strange dreams alongside it.

Behind the Label:
The Effects of
Melatonin
By Krissy González Del Riego
